Advantages:
1) Idioms are like figures of speech in poetry. They help us to understand. " I was so nervous that I had butterflies in my stomach."
2) Idioms , like poetry, can express a great deal in very few words as in
the response to this question. "Are you sure it is okay if we come along
with you to that party?" "Sure, the more, the merrier!"
3) Idioms, like poetic devices, can paint a picture for us. "The newcomer was as uncomfortable as a fish out of water."
4) Sometimes the idioms speakers use give clues about their geographic, social, or occupational background.
That salesman is full of more lies than an Irishman is full of blarney.
Disadvantages:
1) Having taught both English and German as second languages, I know
what a stumbling block idioms can be. How is the English learner to
guess that the literal meaning of "He kicked the bucket?" has nothing to
do with the idiomatic meaning of he died? And when the English speaker
translates the German idiom literally into "I'll take you around the
corner." s/he may think it is someone being friendly to a tourist rather
than issuing a death threat.
2) Even native speakers of the same language but of different
generations can have communication problems because of idioms. Ask any
grandparent how many times s/he has had to rephrase something for a
grandchild who misunderstood a sentence containing an idiom in his or
her own first language because the idiom was outdated?
3) Peers from different parts of the country may not understand each
other because of unfamiliarity with non-local idioms. When my family
had just moved from the Chicago are to California in 1960, my sister,
upon seeing some hideous outfit, remarked to a group of newly-made
girlfriends, "I wouldn't wear that to a dogfight." My sister was quite
surprised when the girls burst into laughter and could not stop. They
had never heard this idiom, which was so common to her that she did not
stop to picture the silly image.
4) Teaching literature becomes more difficult because of idioms because
even the teacher may have to guess at the meaning of antiquated idioms
if no research is available.
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar